From:Illias Suttar
Sent:13-Jan-02
To:Sultan Qureshi
Subject:My challenge was to show...
 

JEWISH AND CHRISTIAN TORAH COMPARED

You have written in your email dated 10-1-2003 as follows:- “” His (Illias Suttar’s) challenge was to show one sentence from Torah (a hanged person is cursed).………………The Challenge has been shattered to pieces”

Dear Sultan Qureshi, you are not discussing in the House of WAX.  Each email address is supposed to represent a LIVING PERSON.

MY ACTUAL CHALLENGE was not just to show in Torah that a hanged person is cursed of God but my CHALLENGE was to show the verse in TORAH printeD by the Jews.

You have quoted 6 CHRISTIAN PRINTS OF TORAH on 5-12-02 as follows:-

(1) Cursed of God (2) Cursed by God (3) Accursed of God (4) Accursed of  God (5) Under God’s Curse (6) Under God’s Curse

BUT the JEWISH prints of Torah quoted by YOU are as follows:

(1) Curse of God (your email dated 6th January 2003)
(2) Curse to God (your email dated 5-12-2002)
(3) affront to God (your email dated 25-11-2002)

How on earth YOU feel that Christian version of “cursed of God” means the same as curse of God or curse to God?
 

The Good News Bible (1977) Printed by Christians themselves gives a VERY CLEAR PICTURE of where the CURSE falls.

Deuteronomy 21 / 22; 23 (Good News Bible)

“(22) If a man has been put to death for a crime and his body is hung on a post, (23) it is not to remain there overnight.  It must be buried the same day, because a DEAD BODY hanging on a post BRINGS God’s Curse ON the LAND.  Bury the body, so that you will not defile the land””

A VERY IMPORTANT OBSERVATION -----------(from SOME Christian Bibles)
Even in ALL SIX quotes of Christian Bibles GIVEN by Sultan Qureshi on 5-12-2002, IT IS CLEARLY mentioned that the man is (1) First put to death (2) Secondly his dead body is hanged on a tree

CURSE IS NOT BECAUSE HE IS HANGED till DEATH, but THE CURSE IS if HE IS HANGED after DEATH.

In the case of Jesus (according to Christians and Ahmadis / Qadianis), it was not a dead person but a LIVE PERSON (Jesus) Nailed to the Cross.

The dead body of Jesus (according to Christians) was NOT hung on the tree after he died BUT buried in the grave.

Since the dead body of Jesus was not hung on the tree AFTER death, So neither according to Christians Jesus died a cursed death, NOR there was any need for the Qadianis / Ahmadis to make Jesus faint on the cross in order to avoid cursed death of hanging.
 
Sultan Qureshi wrote:

Where is 5 lac rupees he promised? Has this been deposited somewhere?
Such a funny man!! He can't keep even his promise of 5 lac rupees. He
must be a businessman, but this is not business:

1) Illias did not put any challenge that the law is divine or not.

2) His challenge was to show one sentence from Torah (a hanged person is
cursed)

The challenge has been shattered into pieces not only from Torah but
also by the verdict of the Holy Quran which he himself accepted.

Alhamdolillah! All praise belongs to Allah!

And proclaim: 'Truth has come and falsehood has vanished. Verily,
falsehood is bound to vanish.' (Holy Quran, Chapter 17: Bani Isra'il)

Sultan Qureshi
A humble servant of Islam

p.s. I'm still waiting for replies to all my points from my pervious
emails. None of the points has been answered yet. Do you want me to
repeat them for you? :)

 

back to top