Author:
 Illias Suttar

 

Can U Answer?
 


From:Illias Suttar [illias@super.net.pk]
Sent:Mon 8/6/2007 12:28 AM
To:All members of the mailing list
Subject:3 PERSONS WITH IDENTIFICATION
 

With the Name of Allah. The Compassionate. The Merciful.
If Allah Wills .What Allah Wills. Peace Be Upon the Holy Prophets

If you write long, people do not read.If you write short,people do not understand.
In debates and discussions where time is limited to one or two hours, many sessions end without any conclusive decisions.

Around 12 years ago, I had initiated a special program in Qartaba Masjid, Bahadurabad , Karachi, Pakistan. Any one could give a speech on Saturday after Isha prayer. After the speech, questions and answers would follow. If no conclusion would take place, no new speaker will come on 2nd Saturday. The question and answer session of 1st Saturday will continue on the 2nd Saturday. If the question and answer session will not end on 2nd Saturday ,it will continue on 3rd, 4th ,5th & 6th Saturdays i.e. till the conclusion is reached, the same topic will continue every Saturday.

On one Saturday the Imam of the mosque gave a speech on  The Holy Quran. According to him, The Holy Quran had no beginning in time. As Allah has no beginning, so The Holy Quran also has no beginning.

The Imam Saheb was asked a number of questions but the 1st session was not conclusive. The 2nd Saturday Started with questions and answers and perhaps on the 3rd Saturday the Imam Saheb was assisted by a madressah teacher, Mr.Abdur Rahman.

The teacher was asked: Who is the creator of German and Japanese languages? The teacher replied: Allah

Who is the creator of English and Urdu languages ?The teacher replied :Allah
Who is the creator of the Arabic language? The teacher replied: Allah

IF ALLAH HAS CREATED THE ARABIC LANGUAGE,THEN THE ARABIC LANGUAGE IS A CREATED ITEM,AND THEREFORE THE ARABIC LANGUAGE HAS A BEGINNING.

IF THE ARABIC LANGUAGE HAS A BEGINNING,AND THE HOLY QURAN IS IN ARABIC,HOW CAN THE HOLY QURAN COME BEFORE THE ARABIC LANGUAGE?

IF ARABIC LANGUAGE HAS A BEGINNING,THEN WHATEVER IS IN ARABIC ALSO HAS A BEGINNING. THEREFORE THE ARABIC HOLY QURAN ALSO HAS A BEGINNING.

SO BECAUSE OF 3 SESSIONS,THE CONCLUSION TOOK PLACE.IF THERE WAS ONLY ONE SESSION , NO CONCLUSION WOULD HAVE TAKEN PLACE.

Request
I want to start the above program with some members of our Discussion Group Since all persons will naturally not be interested in lengthy discussions, I need only 3 persons to bear this program with patience.

Proper identification of the interested person will be a must.
 
 

back to top