From: Illias Suttar [illias@super.net.pk]
Sent: Tuesday, November 04, 2003 5:47 PM
Subject: Rashid

Anti Ahmadiyya Movement in Islam
5th August 1999

In the Name of Allah, The Compassionate, The Merciful.

Peace and Love of Allah be upon Hazrat Muhammad, the Last and Final Prophet after whom there is no prophet.

InshaAllah MashaAllah

Mirza Tahir finally agrees for Mubahila

Mirza Tahir has finally succumbed to the pressure. He had done what he and his predeccesors had always been running away from and had been scared to do: Mubahila. After so many years of challenging and counter challenging of Mubahila by the opponents of Ahmadiyyat and two attempts at Hoax-sitting-at-home-Mubahila in 1988 and 1998 by Mirza Tahir, first time in the history of Ahmadiyyat Khalifa has authorised someone to accept face to face Mubahila on his behalf and sign it in front of witnesses.

MOBAHILLA MOBAHILLA MOBAHILLA

On 20-5-99 a meeting took place in Model Colony, Karachi, between Mr. Illias Suttar and Mohammad Usman. The subject of the meeting was : Challenging the Reward Bearing article of Mr. Illias Suttar: “ Can Ahmadis/ Qadianis Answer ?”. Mr. Mohammad Usman promised to give his answer on 27-5-99 but could not attend the meeting due to some other occupation. Therefore, another meeting took place on 3-6-99. On 3-6-99, Mr. Mohammad Osman instead of giving the answer, offered Mobahilla challenge on behalf of Khalifa Mirza Taher to Mr. Illias Suttar. Mr. Illias Suttar accepted the challenge and said: Since the offer of Mobahilla is from Mr. Mohammad Usman, so the cost of advertisements must be paid by Mr. Mohammad Usman. Mr. Mohammad Usman accepted to meet the cost of advertisement. The full text of the agreement is given below without any change :

On 3rd June, 1999 a meeting took place between Mr. Mohammad Usman (Ahmadi), and Mr. Illias Suttar (non-Ahmadi Muslim), resident of 19, Commercial Area Bahadurabad, Karachi-74800, Pakistan ( phone no. 4937221 ).
Mr. Mohammad Usman is Murabbi of Silsella Ahmadiyya and lives in Baitul Hamd, Martin road, Karachi, Pakistan.

Subject of Meeting: Reward Bearing Question of Illias Suttar
(The article titled, "Can Ahmadis/Qadiyanis Answer ?")

Mr. Mohammad Usman offered Mobahilla challenge on behalf of Mirza Tahir, 4th Khalifa of Ahmadis. Mr. Usman gave a booklet on Mobahilla dated 10-6-1988 issued by Mirza Taher, the Khalifa.

Illias Suttar accepted the Mobahilla challenge and Mr. Mohammad Usman accepted the following conditions :

Illias Suttar will advertise the Mobahilla Acceptance in Pakistani Newspapers and the expenses will be paid by Mr. Mohammad Usman even if the expenses are Rs. 30,000/= (Rupees Thirty Thousand ). Mr. Mohammad Usman will have this Mobahilla Agreement printed in England, etc. in Newspapers and magazines. Illias Suttar will have the Mobahilla Agreement printed and will staple it to his article or add it to the article in future editions.

Illias Suttar prays to Allah :
If Janab Mirza Ghulam Ahmad is WRONG and NOT FROM ALLAH, then in 1 (one) year Janab Mirza Taher, the 4th Khalifa will be punished by Allah. Also Jamat-e-Ahmadiyya will be punished by Allah.

If Illias Suttar is wrong in his points, then Illias Suttar will be punished by Allah in one year. If Mirza Saheb is from Allah, then Illias Suttar will be punished in one year.

Signed by Mr. Illias Suttar (021-4937221) and Mr. Mohammad Usman (021-423426)

Witnessed and signed by following Ahmadis:

Mr. Qudratullah.
Mr.Mohammad Saeed.
Mr. Abdur Rehman.

Witnessed and signed by following non-Ahmadi muslims:

Mr. Shafiq H. Qadri.
Mr. Mir Abduulah.
Mr. Tahir Rasheed.

Dear Readers!
Mirza Tahir has finally succumbed to the pressure. He had done what he and his predeccesors had not done, and had been scared to do: Mubahila. After so many years of challenging and counter challenging of Mubahila by the opponents of Ahmadiyyat and several attempts at Hoax-sitting-at-home-Mubahila over the years by Mirza Tahir and his predeccesors, this is the first time that Mirza Tahir has authorised someone to accept face to face Mubahila on his behalf and sign it in front of witnesses. Now the Mubahila is on. Matters are in the hands of Allah. Let us see what happens. However Mirza Tahir has very cleverly chosen the words: The whole Jamaat Ahmadiyya has been included in it. The implication? Even if something happens to Mirza Tahir as a result to Mubahila, they can still try to wriggle out of this mubahila by saying that look at the Jamaat, nothing has happened to it!!

Wassalam

Dr. Syed Rashid Ali
P O Box 11560
Dibba Fujairah
United Arab Emirates
rasyed@emirates.net.ae
http://alhafeez.org/rashid/